COGNITION

Studies in psychology and sociology.


these links are still under construction and are subject to change. Even the context of this series of documents may change as comprehension develops.


Consonant: In harmony or agreementl; accord. 2. harmonious in tone: opposed to dissonant Congruent: to come together, correspond, agree with

ATTITUDES
PARADIGMS
  • ...a more or less permanently enduring state of readiness of mental organization which predisposes an individual to react in a characteristic way to any object or situation with which it is related. (Cantril, 1934)
  • The attitude, or preparation in advance of the actual response, constitutes an important determinant of the ensuing social behavior. Such neural settings, with their accompanying consciousness, are numerous and significant in social life. (F. H. Allport, 1924)
  • An attitude, roughly, is a residuum of experience, by which further activity is conditioned and controlled . . . We may think of attitudes as acquired tendencies to act in specific ways toward objects. (Kruger and Recklass, 1931)
  • An attitude is a mental and neural state of readiness, organized through experience, exerting a directive or dynamic influence upon the individual's response to all objects and situations with which it is related. (G. Allport, 1935)
  • A paradigm is an organizing principle which can govern perception (p. 113)
  • A paradigm determines large areas of experience at the same time, including which facts are gathered, permitting selection, evaluation, and criticism in scientific activity. (p. 122, 126)
  • A paradigm is a standard upon which to recognize [judge] the existence of an anomaly, and thus allow the recognition of a possible problem caused by the error or anomaly. (p. 18, 65)
  • A paradigm can guide research in the absence of rules and is more global than rules. (pp. 42-43)
  • A paradigm limits the nature of acceptable solutions and methods used to attain them; it makes scientists committed to certain conceptual, theoretical, instrumental, and methodological commitments which are derived from the paradigm (p. 42)

A Conceptual Framework and Some Empirical Data Regarding Comparisons of Social Rewards
Martin Patchen
Sociometry, Vol. 24, No. 2
(Jun., 1961), 136-156.
  • This study demonstrates the motivation in humans to compare themselves with other people.
  • Uses wages and wage related attributes as the most immediate and convenient method of comparison, and shows that socioeconomic status is the prevalent method of comparison.
  • Defines some components of social stratification.
  • Explains some behavior patterns of groups of satisfied, neutral, and dissatisfied people.
  • Explains some behaviors of corporations toward instilling dissonance within the workforce.
    • Retail store managers are hired from outside the store and not promoted from within the store, as a message to the employees that "you don't have a future here, so don't stay long enough to earn full benefits."
  • Supports the argument on the Effects of Television on the Public By demonstrating the human tendency to seek visual cues of social status and to readily adopt perceived authoritative sources of information as opinion leaders, such as mass media outlets.
Attitudinal Consequences of Induced Discrepancies Between Cognition and Behavior
Arthur R. Cohen
the Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol 24, No. 2, Special Issue: Attitude Changes (Summer 1960), 297-318
  • Students subjected to embarrassing and unpleasant experiences in the attainment of group membership placed a high value upon such memberships.
  • Different groups of school children were given varying degrees of reward for writing essays in favor of shorter summer vacations. The high reward group showed less actual change in attitude in a post-test than the low reward group.
  • Less becomes more and more becomes less. Cohen's findings elude to the twinkling of something just under the surface of human awareness. That switch under the murky waters of consciousness that causes paradigm shifts.
Cognition: Exploring the Science of the Mind. (Chapter 3: Paying Attention)
Daniel Reisberg
(c)1997 By W. W. Norton & Company, Inc. ISBN: 0-393-96925-8
  • You choose that, to which you pay attention, and choose to be virtually oblivious to other things.
  • It is difficult to pay attention to everything at once. New environments make it difficult to focus initially.
  • Internal contemplation is as much a distraction as the environment.
  • You can choose to divide your attention between two inputs at once.
  • Ignoring is an active process, not a passive process
  • the content of the ignored message is ignored, but the conditions of the ignored source can be remembered.
  • Something outside your focused attention can catch your attention if you are sufficiently primed for it (such as repeated exposures to a brand, the name of a movie you saw, or something personal and prevalent).
  • Some people require more practice to tune out the other conversations at a cocktail party
  • Having just ignored a stimulus, it is now a bit harder to pay attention to that stimulus.
  • Our attention can be preprogrammed to be sensitive to certain stimuli. Called "Selective Priming"
Cognitive Dissonance and the Effectiveness of Persuasive Communications
James O. Whittaker the Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol. 28, No. 4 (Winter, 1964), 547-555.
  • This paper defines a "latitude of acceptance" of messages that is surrounded by "latitudes of rejection" on both sides. Within a range that is not quantified, a message may be accepted and an attitude changed.
  • Messages too extreme are rejected and barriers of resistance are employed.
  • Messages of no consequence are simply ignored or are only temporarily and finitely effective.
  • This paper describes methods used to bring a passive audience into an active mode for Public Relations work.
  • Relies on values transmitted through the act of social comparison
Consumer Behavior.
Bennett, Peter D.; Kassarjian, Harold H.
Foundation of Marketing Series
©1972 Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.
ISBN 0-13-169383-2
  • You believe that you see everything around you, but you don't. This book explains the components of an attitude, how an attitude is developed, and how our attitudes dictate what we perceive around us, and ultimately, how we are herded into our socially stratified classes and cultures.
Continuities in theories of Status Consistency and Cognitive Dissonance
James A. Geschwender Wayne State University
Social Forces, Vol. 46, No. 2 (Dec., 1967), 160-171
  • Cognitive Dissonance as it applies toward one's own social status.
  • The disparity between perceived behavioral expectations and real behavioral expectations.
  • Behaviors that indicate perception of social status.
  • This paper quantifies and segments important audiences and is highly applicable to Public Relations in that certain audiences are to be avoided, or at least, the appearance that certain audiences are being avoided should be maintained..
Cultural Criminology
Jeff Ferrell; Clinton Sanders, [editors]
© 1995 Northeastern University Press
ISBN 1-55553-235-7
  • the mass media's responsibility for "engineering reality", generating "cultural norms."
  • Moral Entrepreneurs and media generated "moral panics."
  • How the news media triggered a democratic shift to the right in New York in the 1980's.
  • The codependency of journalists and the"authorities."
  • The public's gradual acceptance of fewer constitutional rights and harsher treatment of crime suspects.
  • Thesimplistic focus on symptoms of problems rather than the sources of problems.
Dissonance theory and Receptivity to Structural Perceptions of the Causes of Urban Crime
Glen Broach, East Tennessee State University
the Western Political Quarterly, Vol. 27, No. 3. (Sep., 1974), 491-499
  • This paper draws upon the Eisenhower Commission and the Kerner Commission on Civil Disorders to understand the perceptions of social problems by civic leaders, particularly with regards to poverty and civil rights policies. This paper follows several civil rights conflicts and during the Vietnam War.
  • "Traditional, middle-class morality places emphasis upon perceptions which regard criminal behavior as the result of individual personal failing, with blame resting and retribution focusing on the individual committing the act."
  • This paper actually tests the responses of people to alternative explanations of crime, and develops categories of responses similar to Homeostatic theory.
Dissonance-Congruence and the Perception of Public Opinion.
Kenneth W. Eckhardt; Gerry Hendershot. TheAmerican Journal of Sociology, Vol. 73, No. 2 (Sep., 1967), 226-234
  • Individuals seek to validate their attitudes, opinions, and behaviors.
  • Individuals seek to make related attitudes, opinions, and behaviors consistent.
  • This paper quantifies the disparity of perception of public opinion and actual public opinion. Similar to the question of status consistency above. But this paper develops a four segment typology that may be adaptable to the status consistency dissonance. The two papers were composed in the same year, 1967.
Homeostatic theory in Attitude Change
Nathan Maccoby; Eleanor E. Maccoby
the Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol. 25, No. 4 (Winter 1961), 538-545
  • This paper analyzes several approaches to attitude change and develops a theory based upon "...a kind of balance of forces approach in which the overloading of one type of factor gives rise to changes designed to restore balance." The research draws some conclusions about behavior that is alternative to attitude change. People have alternatively:
    • strengthened The original attitude and discounted The source of The conflicting communication.
    • Simply refusing to attend The message, or repressing or deverbalizing it once The message is received.
    • Compartmentalizing or fractionalizing The attitude so that The inconsistencies are not so readily apparent.
  • Some people can tolerate ambiguity and inconsistency, and even seek it. Some have parlayed dissonance into a very lucrative career in mass media.
Internal Versus External Criticism of Groups Standards
Sumiko Iwao
Sociometry, Vol. 26, No 4. (Dec., 1963)
410-421
  • Iwao tested a group of Jewish divinity students against a group of gentiles and found by accident that there was a "delayed dissonance arousal" affect. Special cultural cohesiveness differences between Jews and Gentiles may have played a more significant role than predicted, possibly resulting in a Pygmalion Paradox (A study becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy). Nevertheless, Contradictory statements made from within a group were tolerated more than those from another group.
  • Thestudy works under The premises of some of Festinger's behaviors for reducing dissonance
    • Derogating The person who is in disagreement (Attacking The messenger's credibility)
    • Eliminate The disagreement
      • by changing his or her own opinion.
      • By attempting to influence The disagreeing person
    • Convince him or her self that The evidence is unimportant.
    • Seek additional social support for The original opinion
MEDIA, PROCESS, AND The SOCIAL CONSTRUCTION OF CRIME
Studies in Newsmaking Criminology.
Edited By Gregg Barak (c)1994 Gregg Barak. Garland Publishing, Inc. New York, London
ISBN 0-8153-1259-8
  • News is split into two functions that ultimately reinforce The authority of The dominant social order.
    • Reporting of threats to The social order as well as The resulting efforts to restore order.
    • Routine activities that reinforce The power of The dominant social order.
  • Instead of reflecting The increasingly greater diversity, The news media has continued to provide homogenized, mainstream, and uniform versions of reality that tend to avoid fundamental controversy.
  • Thenews media consistently underplay petty, nonviolent, and white-collar offenses while they overplay interpersonal, violent, and sexual crimes. Invariably, media portrayals of criminals tend to be one-dimensional reflections of The crimes commonly committed By The poor and The powerless and not those crimes commonly committed By The rich and powerful.
Misattribution of Arousal as a Means of Dissonance Reduction
David Drachman; Steven Worchel
Sociometry, Vol. 39, No. 1
(Mar., 1976), 53-59
  • Suddenly, you remember why you were angry and it had nothing to do with The dog.
  • "Theperson experiencing The dissonance may at times misattribute his arousal to a source other than The discrepant cognitions responsible for The arousal."
  • People tend to misdirect their anger (dissonance) or frustration toward The distant or defenseless in order to avoid confronting The original source directly.
  • There is a suggestion that a person actively seeks a target of dissonance reduction from The immediate environment. The result is inexplicable behavior such as road rage, or spousal or child abuse.
Quasi-Mass Communication: A Neglected Area
Herbert Menzel
The Public Opinion Quarterly, Vol. 35, No. 3
(Autumn 1971), 406-409
  • Theneglected middle ground between Interpersonal Communication and Mass Communication.
  • Touches on The channels of communication available to small groups before The creation of The Internet and before cable television's segmentation of The American Public.
TheBoundary of The Self-Fulfilling Prophecy and The Dilemma of Social Prediction
Richard L. Henshel
TheBritish Journal of Sociology, Vol. 33, No. 4 (Dec., 1982), 511-528.
A summary of areas where Self Fulfilling Prophecy, and Self-Defeating Prophecy has been detected. The author pushes The envelope to The outer limits of perception in order to try and recognize that which remains mostly unrecognizable to The rest of us, The habitualization of our conduct to undesirable ends.
TheDevil Shift: Perceptions and Misperceptions of Opponents
Paul Sabatier; Susan Hunter; Susan McLaughlin
TheWestern Political Quarterly, Vol. 40, No. 3 (Sep., 1987), 449-476
  • This paper involves social status and comparison
  • Precisely explains why certain audiences are to be avoided as stated above. A good argument for at least maintaining The appearance that a Public Relations campaign is deliberately avoiding a certain audience for reasons of social stratification.
  • This paper codifies audiences that are likely to be hostile toward others and each other by explaining beliefs and value systems.
TheEconomic Consequences of Cognitive Dissonance
George A. Alerlof; William T. Dickens TheAmerican Economic Review, Vol. 72, No. 3 (Jun. 1982), 307-319.
  • "Persons not only have preferences over states of The world, but also over their beliefs about The state of The world."
  • People tend not to think about long term consequences. Young people tend not to save for their retirement or even think about their retirement. Proof that we need a Social Security Program.
  • People tend not to think about The safety of their current working conditions or living conditions, so they avoid buying safety equipment,
  • Persons prefer to think of themselves as nice people, and will lower their opinion of people to which they inflict cruelty, whether The cruelty was deliberate or not. This paper sheds some light on adolescent social manipulation. How people act weird towards you because they heard someone mock you.
Dale Carnegie's How to Win Friends and Influence People
  • This process requires selflessness and sacrifice of one's own dignity and pride.
  • A simple approach to getting people to do what you want them to do.